The Economic Fist Fight

The Economic Fist Fight


The two fighters were nice enough to each other. They exchanged pleasantries, took their places on the stage, and then began to trade their blows.

This took place at our Irrational Economic Summit over the weekend when David Stockman and Lacy Hunt squared off and went at it. The topic was the Fed – or more specifically, the Fed's latest bond-buying program, and what it means for the economy.

To Stockman, the Fed's new program to buy $60 billion per month of U.S. one-month T-bills is yet another example of quantitative easing, where the Fed magically prints money and expands credit while crowding private investors out of the T-bill market. The laws of supply and demand haven't been suspended, so Stockman reasons that the extra purchasing will drive up prices and drive down interest rates.

Lacy, in his southerly Texan way, disagreed.

To him, the Fed is simply taking care of a housekeeping issue that should never have been allowed to exist. The Fed controls money supply, and is well aware of the consequences of the Systemically Important Financial Institution (SIFI) designation. Financial companies tagged with SIFI must hold larger, higher quality capital cushions than others, so they aren't as likely to lend their deposits to other banks. As excess reserves eased out of the banking system through increasing loans and the dwindling Fed balance sheet, institutions of many types couldn't get their hands on enough cash to meet their short-term, and often overnight, obligations.

The repo market, where such institutions can borrow money for a day or two, ran out of cash. There weren't enough lenders to meet demand. The Fed is buying very short-term Treasury Bills just to put enough cash in the system to grease the repo wheels.

Two Experts at Work

In a way, both Stockman and Hunt were right. By definition it's quantitative easing, but the effects on the bond market should be negligible.

The sparring was fun to watch, and then moved on to other topics. Should we return to the gold standard? Should the Fed adjust money supply and interest rates? Should the Fed exist at all? Every topic drew a sharp, smart response from both sides, which were often at odds.

David Stockman is certain the Fed has little purpose. Market forces should be allowed to discover prices, which will show up as interest rates on bonds, loans, and deposits.

Dr. Hunt sees the Fed as a bedrock of our monetary system, but thinks they've overplayed their hand and done things since the financial crisis that, while well-intended, have created huge, misaligned asset prices.

This rapid-fire exchange between two men distinguished in their fields exemplified the 2019 Irrational Economic Summit, and explains why I always look forward to these events, and come away mentally exhausted!

If you weren't fortunate enough to be there or watch it live, visit our website and get access on demand, it's definitely worth your time!

One Big Test

As Lacy and Stockman went back and forth, it reminded me that we're in the middle of a huge financial experiment. Central banks around the world printed $26 trillion of new money since the financial crisis, while governments went further into debt. As Lacy pointed out, every time in history that a developed nation has incurred large amounts of debt, it has endured a period of austerity to unwind the debt and get back to normal GDP growth.

This time, as we face a $22 trillion national debt and GDP growth of just 2%, our central bank has already deployed the tools in its arsenal.

I'm not sure exactly what the financial austerity ahead looks like, but I'll bet that it means bursting asset bubble prices in many areas, including stocks and real estate. That's an outcome on which even Lacy Hunt and David Stockman seemed to agree.

Rodney Johnson's signature

Rodney Johnson

Trending Stories...

Global Trends, Market Red Flags & Rare Money-Making Ideas: IES Wrap-Up

The 7th Annual Irrational Economic Summit has officially come to an end. This by far was the best, most contrarian event yet. With over 260 attendees filling the conference rooms each day and another 250+ livestream viewers, savvy investors got direct access to strategies and insights from the brightest Wall Street analysts and economists in...

Little-Known, Market-Tested Strategies to Grow Your Money: Live from IES

Yesterday kicked off Day 1 of the 2019 Irrational Economic Summit, and was by far one of the best days since this event started in 2012. Mark Yusko If you have even a dime of your money in the market, the research-backed insights from Morgan Creek Capital Management's CEO Mark Yusko, alone, could get you...

It's a Mad Market: Live from the Irrational Economic Summit

As you know, this week myself and the Dent Research team are at the National Harbor outside Washington DC for the 7th annual Irrational Economic Summit. Festivities kicked off Thursday, and it was simply a great day – and Friday and Saturday should be just as wonderful. (You can get fully caught up, and even...

Craziness in the Markets: Live from the Irrational Economic Summit

The 2019 Irrational Economic Summit is already off to a big start. The Irrational Economic Summit opened with a full house of 260 attendees. Boom & Bust co-editor Rodney Johnson drove home the importance of pinpointing the right information, at the right time, to take the right action on your money. "We don't just give...

The Game-Changing Event of the Year Kicks Off Tomorrow

Harry and Rodney are in the air today, onboard separate planes bound for Washington DC and the 7th Annual Irrational Economic Summit, set for Thursday through Saturday at the National Harbor. They'll be checking in throughout the conference, and we're also excited to feature Economy & Markets reporter Llacey Simmons through the week. Llacey will...

No comments:

Post a Comment